The Best Transcription Services for 2023
Human-generated transcription means a human worker listens to an audio recording and manually types what they hear. Automated transcripts come from a machine doing the job instead. Both have their pros and cons. Here we list the best transcription services we found based on our hands-on testing. Read on after the list to find more information on what to look for in a transcription service, the difference between automated and human transcription, and other details you should know about transcription services.
People need audio files transcribed for a variety of reasons. Whether you’re a legal professional who relies on having recorded depositions turned into text, or a journalist looking to pull that perfect quote from a long interview, you need accurate audio transcription. Previously, the act of taking recorded speech and turning it into text was tedious and done only manually. Technology is changing things. In the last decade, the transcription services market has exploded with a variety of companies that provide both automated and human-created transcriptions.
Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. See how we test. (Opens in a new window)
Deeper Dive: Our Top Tested Picks
Mục lục bài viết
Rev
Best Overall
5.0 Exemplary
Why We Picked It
Rev is our top choice transcription service for several reasons: It works flawlessly, has intuitive software, and offers a variety of options to meet every need. Rev lets you choose whether you want an AI- or human-generated transcription, with a fast turnaround. It also has a great collaborative web space for teams to work together on projects. Since the first time we looked at Rev in 2018, the company has only improved. Between its à la carte services, subscription plan, several mobile apps, and unlimited Zoom meeting transcriptions, Rev has a lot of options that work for a variety of professional needs.
Who It’s For
Rev is best for professionals who use a transcription service regularly. A subscription includes 20 hours of audio recordings transcribed per month for a flat $29.99 per month. It’s the best value, as long as you need all those hours. Rev also offers non-subscription services, which are better for people who only occasionally need to transcribe a file.
PROS
- Option for AI or human transcriptions, plus subtitles and captions
- Web editing and group collaboration features
- Easy-to-navigate website
- Fast turnaround times
- Few errors
CONS
- Mobile apps not integrated with web subscriptions
- Expensive
GET IT NOW
Today’s Best Deal
(Opens in a new window)
Learn More
Rev Review
Scribie
Best for Occasional Use
3.5 Good
Why We Picked It
While Scribie doesn’t have as many features as Rev, it does have some of the lowest prices on the market for accurate and reliable transcriptions. Scribie doesn’t have a mobile app and its website is a bit clunky, but its prices are tough to beat. It also has a subscription plan that knocks off a few more pennies per audio minute, which makes sense for high-volume users. When we put Scribie up against other transcription services, it made few errors and produced a fairly clean document.
Who It’s For
Scribie is best for users who do not need a large volume of transcription and don’t require mobile apps or an advanced web-based editor. For those who need affordable automated and manual transcriptions only occasionally, Scribie is a solid product that performs as advertised.
PROS
- Inexpensive
- Accurate transcriptions in our testing
- Company will sign an NDA upon request
CONS
- Confusing web interface
- No mobile app
GET IT NOW
Visit Site Scribie
(Opens in a new window)
Learn More
Scribie Review
GoTranscript
Best for Human-Generated Transcripts
4.5 Outstanding
Why We Picked It
GoTranscript is a clear winner when you need low-cost human-generated transcriptions. While AI transcription has improved greatly in recent years, nothing compares in accuracy with human transcription. At only 90 cents per minute, GoTranscript is the most affordable human transcription service we found. If you deliver a clear audio file, you can expect to get back a near-verbatim transcription that will leave you impressed.
Who It’s For
GoTranscript is best for users who need highly accurate human transcriptions at the lowest possible price. While other services like Rev and Scribie offer the option of choosing an AI or human transcription every time you make an order, their prices for human transcription are higher than what you pay for GoTranscript.
PROS
- Low price for human transcriptions
- Great website
- Many languages supported
- Incredibly accurate
- Industry-specific transcriptionists available
CONS
- Only offers manual transcriptions (no automated option)
- No autosave while editing
- Standard turnaround time is five days
GET IT NOW
Today’s Best Deal
(Opens in a new window)
Learn More
GoTranscript Review
TranscribeMe
Best for Low-Cost AI Transcription
4.0 Excellent
Why We Picked It
TranscribeMe has the lowest price on the market for automated transcription at just 7 cents per minute. We also picked TranscribeMe for the variety of other services it offers, such as industry-specific transcriptions, translation, and data annotation services. Additionally, TranscribeMe’s website is streamlined and intuitive to use. One unique advantage of TranscribeMe is if you buy an AI transcript and find it’s not to your expectations, you can upgrade it to a human-powered transcription by simply paying the price difference.
Who It’s For
TranscribeMe makes the most sense for users who need a large quantity of transcription but aren’t worried about verbatim documents. For example, the low price for automated transcription makes TranscribeMe perfect for finding important quotes to pull from a longer interview, such as a journalist might do.
PROS
- Very low price for AI transcriptions
- Specializes in multiple industries like legal and medical fields
- Easy to upgrade from AI to human transcription
CONS
- Human transcriptions can take up to five days
- Team accounts difficult to find
GET IT NOW
Visit Site TranscribeMe
(Opens in a new window)
Learn More
TranscribeMe Review
Otter
Best for Free Transcriptions
3.5 Good
Why We Picked It
Otter has developed a solid reputation for transcription services since arriving on the scene in 2016. It has a mobile app and Chrome extension, and a pretty affordable Pro plan for users who need more than the occasional transcription. Otter’s free plan is generous, too, with 300 minutes per month. Otter can also attend virtual meetings if you’re double-booked and send you a transcript of what you’ve missed.
Who It’s For
Otter makes the most sense for anyone who regularly transcribes a few files, but typically does not have a large volume of work for transcription. Sure, Otter’s regular rate is competitive, but the free minutes each month mean that for many users, Otter will meet their needs without charging them a dime.
PROS
- Generous free plan
- Supports major video conferencing platforms
- Modern, easy-to-use mobile apps
- Excellent transcription editing and collaborative tools
CONS
- Poor accuracy score for complex audio test
- Below-average accuracy score for simple audio test
- Real-time transcription struggles to keep up with natural speech
- No multifactor authentication for individual accounts
GET IT NOW
Visit Site Otter.ai
(Opens in a new window)
Learn More
Otter Review
Trint
Best for Single-Speaker Audio and Video Files
3.5 Good
Why We Picked It
Trint has excellent online editing software and offers a great mobile app. It only has a subscription model—there’s no option to pay as you go—making it an outlier among the transcription services we reviewed. The base price is steep at $60 per month for seven automated transcriptions. However, Trint has one feature other services do not: It is able to stitch text to video and produce an SEO-searchable video that can be embedded into your website.
Who It’s For
Trint is the clear choice for users who are building a platform or business using mostly video content. The ability to add searchable captions to videos is an invaluable tool for growing your platform and driving more traffic to your website.
PROS
- Transcribes simple recordings with reasonable accuracy
- Powerful online editor
- Slick and responsive mobile app
- Can add closed captioning to video and audio files
CONS
- Expensive
- Poor accuracy for complex files in testing
- App interface needs more sharing tools
GET IT NOW
Visit Site Trint
(Opens in a new window)
Learn More
Trint Review
Buying Guide: The Best Transcription Services for 2023
Automated vs. Human Transcriptions: What’s the Difference?
Automated transcription services use automatic speech recognition to transcribe an audio file into text. Two primary benefits of using automation are it’s fast and it’s cheap.
Services that offer automated transcription sometimes include extra features that may not be free in a human-generated transcript, such as time stamps and basic speaker identification (for example, Speaker 1, Speaker 2). The downside of automated services is that they are far less accurate than when a human does the job.
Automated transcription services often include access to document editing software which allows you to clean up the text. If you see an error in the document, click on the time-stamped section to listen to the words, and transcribe that portion on your own.
Rev, Otter, Scribie, TranscribeMe, Trint, and Temi (which didn’t score high enough to be included in this list of the best transcription services) all offer automated transcription services. Rev, Scribie, and TranscribeMe also offer human-powered services.
Human-generated transcription services, by contrast, use trained transcriptionists, often more than one, to complete the work. Transcriptions made by humans are highly accurate, but they’re also pricier and typically require a longer turnaround time, although often you have the option to pay extra for a quicker turnaround time. When you choose human-generated transcripts, you can sometimes pay to get a transcriptionist who’s educated in a particular industry’s jargon, such as legal or medical terms.
Using human-powered transcription may introduce some privacy concerns. In testing and reviewing transcription services, we asked each company under what conditions it would comply with law enforcement and hand over any user data. You can read the complete details in the review of each service. All services that made this list of the best transcription services operate under strict nondisclosure policies and let you remove your files from their servers at any time.
How Much Do Transcription Services Cost?
Many transcription services charge on a per-minute basis. For example, a 30-minute transcription at $1 per minute would cost $30. Costs can add up quickly, and some services bill extra for a faster turnaround time, verbatim files (meaning they include all the “ums” and “ahs”), or if the audio is of poor quality. If you find yourself transcribing audio and video files often, a subscription-based service, such as those offered by Otter and Trint, might be the best value for you.
As you might guess, the amount of time it takes to turn around a file usually depends on its length. Automated services can typically process a file in a matter of minutes. Human-powered services take quite a bit longer and you may have to pay for faster delivery speeds. Rev is simple in that it promises to return your file (in most cases) in a 12-hour timeframe. GoTranscript’s slowest option (five days) is also its cheapest.
How to Get the Most Accurate Transcription
One of the most important things you can do to ensure an accurate transcription is to capture a high-quality recording of a conversation or interview in the first place. It is vital that your subjects are close to the recording device and speak in loud, clear voices. When you have multiple speakers, participants should only speak one at a time to avoid interference. Most services also point out that speakers with heavy accents can pose some issues, though there’s not much you can do to avoid it. Audio editing software such as Audacity can clear up some issues, but it’s not a miracle worker. In-person recordings also produce better results than recordings of phone calls.
In general, automated services are only useful if the audio recording is on the simple side and you don’t need perfectly accurate results. They’re fine for personal voice memos and similar applications, but not for a professional setting.
How to Edit a Transcription
Chances are you’ll need to correct some parts of your transcript once you receive it. Most services include a built-in editor for making these changes before you export the final document. Typically, these interfaces combine playback controls with a text editor. The setup is much more convenient than switching between a document and an audio player every couple of minutes. In the case of human-powered transcription services, these web editors are often just modified versions of what the transcriptionists use.
Some editing interfaces include tools for highlighting selected parts of a transcript or editing the start time of the recording. Playback speeds and quick rewind buttons (all controllable via keyboard shortcuts) are also fairly standard. GoTranscript is notably the only service that does not offer an online editor. Your only option is to edit the exported transcript after GoTranscript completes a job.
The Best Transcription Apps
Many of the transcription services we reviewed, including GoTranscript, Otter, and Rev also offer mobile apps in addition to their web dashboards. Most offer both Android apps and iPhone apps. For the most part, these apps function as digital voice recorders, though you can also order transcripts of your recordings directly from your mobile device. The drawback is that you can’t import audio files or links the way that you can via their respective websites. Many let you view the completed transcript directly on your device. Otter goes one step further than the others by giving you excellent organizational features and the ability to edit transcripts on the go.
Manual vs. Automated Transcription
If you want to avoid transcription services entirely—for privacy reasons or to save on costs—there are alternatives. For doing your own manual transcription, Transcribe(Opens in a new window) is a great option at only $20 per year. It lets you listen to an audio recording while you type, with built-in keyboard shortcuts and useful playback modes that reduce the number of times you need to pause and rewind. Another option is oTranscribe(Opens in a new window). It works similarly to Transcribe, but it’s free.
If you’re a Microsoft 365 subscriber (not a free user, but a paying subscriber), you can use Transcribe for Word, which is available in the web version of Microsoft Word. You can record in real time using Word, or upload audio files to the automated transcription service. Transcribe for Word doesn’t cost any extra.
For those who don’t want to spend any money, Google Docs may be the best solution. With Google Docs, you can use the voice typing feature, which is nothing more than a speech-to-text tool, to put words down on the page. It’s often quicker than typing everything out. Some people listen to a prerecorded audio file on headphones and then speak the same lines aloud to a speech-to-text tool, which works better than playing the audio directly into a microphone, but it’s still cumbersome and takes time.
Ultimately, any transcription method or service you choose is better than simply letting your recordings go to waste. Yes, transcribing can be a hassle and some services are costly, but the value of accurate and usable transcripts far outweighs these annoyances. At least one of the services named above should suit your needs. Make sure to read our full reviews for help picking the right one.
